I don’t get the whole “personal brand” thing.
To me, it sounds like you put your personal branding iron over hot coals and burn your initials into your forehead.
Good God, bloggers are turning into cattle with this whole branding thing. Very competitive cattle, for that matter.
I hate that expression. I think it’s the dumbest. I do.
“Personal Brands”. *Rolls eyes*
It could be that I don’t get it and perhaps I’m missing out on something truly exponentially GINORMOUSLY paramount in the blogging world. But, I don’t understand what it really is, and honestly, why it is even important. Then again, I’m a blogger who really only cares about the writing and the friendship part of the online world.
When a company approaches me, that’s an added bonus, I suppose. Yes, I’ve graciously accepted the generously bestowed upon me products and I’ve blogged a review with full disclosure and integrity. But the free shit? That’s not even close to why I started blogging, hell, I didn’t even know about THAT side of blogging back at the beginning!
I’ve been feeling sort disconnected lately, between the major serious blockage and the lack of branding knowledge. It’s put me in a serious bloggy funk.
Until yesterday. I woke up to find a comment from a local Twitter friend, DamnRedHead, Stacy Lukasavitz, That Damn Red Head…
Stacy Lukasavitz says:
March 4, 2010 at 11:22 pm (Edit)
You know what? I don’t read many blogs that would be considered in your “genre,” per se, but I love yours, and I tell people about it in person a lot. You know why? Not because you’re local (although that does help), but because you’re REAL. You don’t bother with the facetiousness and the bullshit of “personal branding” and all that crap, you’re just you, and you tell it like it is in your world and how you see the rest of it. And I respect that more than you can imagine. Seriously. I can’t say any more on this post than “keep up the good work” but I thought I’d tell you like it is, like I see it, because you’re one of the most authentic people online I’ve ever “met,” and I thought you should know. One of these days I hope we could have coffee or beers or something. You’re awesome and I love you for being real, for being you.
… and also for leaving the shoulder pads in the ’80s.
And that comment. Those words from an online friend whom I’ve never met…yet hope to in the very VERY near future…
It’s amazing how, sometimes someone comes along and without realizing it, puts your confusing shit into a nice, neat perspective.
Who gives a fuck.
Seriously.
I’m a blogger and a wannabe writer. I refuse to call myself a brand. I’m not a
–noun
1.
kind, grade, or make, as indicated by a stamp, trademark, or the like: the best brand of coffee.
2.
a mark made by burning or otherwise, to indicate kind, grade, make, ownership, etc.
3.
a mark formerly put upon criminals with a hot iron.
4.
any mark of disgrace; stigma.
5.
branding iron.
6.
a kind or variety of something distinguished by some distinctive characteristic: The movie was filled with slapstick—a brand of humor he did not find funny.
7.
a burning or partly burned piece of wood.
8.
Archaic. a sword.
–verb (used with object)
9.
to label or mark with or as if with a brand.
10.
to mark with disgrace or infamy; stigmatize.
11.
to impress indelibly: The plane crash was branded on her mind.
12.
to give a brand name to: branded merchandise.
13.
to promote as a brand name.
as found in dictionary.com
I’m just me. Melissa Beth Steinberg Brodsky. Nothing less. And growing more.
THIS? Is my blog.
My blog and I? We don’t care about being a brand. We care about being true to ourselves. Being the best person, blogger, mom, wife, friend, daughter, sister, aunt, etc…that we can be.
And that. Is that.

#1 by Stacy Lukasavitz on March 6, 2010 - 11:24 am
Quote
AWWWWW!! WOW. To my knowledge, I’ve never had that kind of affect on a blogger from a comment I made … to be truthful, I was tired, I was a little tipsy, and I clicked over to your blog that night because I wanted to see what the latest was in your life, and I appreciate a great writer (which you are). I read your post and when I’m in that state, I just let my true feelings rip. Sometimes it’s dangerous but it’s always sincere.
My fear is that this is going to spark a big long debate about personal branding here, and I’d really hate to see that. I’ve tried to avoid writing my own post dedicated to my feelings on “personal branding” because I rant about it enough in person and in comments.
Truth be told, I actually admire the people that are banking on the “personal branding” thing, like Dan Schwabel. The core of it all, at least what I understand, is to be the best person you can be and to let that be known, let yourself and what you stand for stand out in someone’s mind and I can’t really argue with that. I do know that a lot of people have trouble grasping the concept of “be yourself,” even as adults, and if subscribing to the “personal branding” philosophy helps them, GREAT.
But at the same time, one shouldn’t HAVE to work at it.
It’s when people that strive to let their “personal brand” be something that they’re not that really gets me.
Personally, I’m just me and I always have been. Many people think that “that damn redhead” is some kind of brand I’ve worked hard to attain, and nothing could be further from the truth. It’s a silly curse that people always said when I was around, then it became kind of a joke, then it became a screen name, etc. It just happened.
As I said in the comments of my own blog recently:
I am not a brand. This is who I am. I don’t try. I’m a real person, not a persona. Michael Jordan is a brand — he has shoes named after him. Vera Wang is a brand — she has dresses and mattresses named after her. I am a regular person who coincidentally (not luckily) was nicknamed after a malediction.
Stacy Lukasavitz´s last blog ..Mozes provides mobile marketing miracles for mobs.
#2 by Melissa on March 6, 2010 - 11:34 am
Quote
“It’s when people that strive to let their “personal brand” be something that they’re not that really gets me.”
and that is why i don’t try to brand myself. because i’d be so obviously trying too hard. i am not a business person, in any sense of the word. i just love to write, whether or not it’s great is debatable, but the passion is there none-the-less. and that…is the only brand of me that i would promote. my competent writing. and my good looks, of course
but seriously, your comment, whether drunk typing or not, came at a perfect time of bloggy introspection for me. i’ve been thinking about shutting down because of it not getting any bigger, not making much money, etc.
then you left that comment and it was like someone took me and gave me shaking…
who the heck cares what other people think, how much money i’m making from it and what “brands” are seeking me out.
i’m me. my blog is still a reflection of me. and i haven’t sold out on myself.
yes, i respect people who register their name for a trademark and make money off of their personal brand. maybe if i knew how, i would too. after all, i could use the extra money, with 5 kids and another bat mitzvah quickly approaching.
but like i said. i’m me. this is my blog. and what you see here is what you get in real life. except with blushing. and maybe my sister is right and i’m not as entertaining in person. although, i like to think i am.
#3 by Tina on March 6, 2010 - 11:35 am
Quote
Great entry Melissa….really made me think…yes, I am guilty of creating a “personal branding” blog entry but I guess I don’t think of it in the way of the mainstream. I decided that my “personal brand” would be about me, my likes/dislikes, being fun and happy, what I am passionate about (seeing Detroit succeed), and trying to help others see the good in Detroit as well.
I guess for me it is more the “theme, mood, etc” that I want to portray. I also love our blog and don’t change a thing…Keep up the good work.
Tina
Tina´s last blog ..Are you on the Titanic?
#4 by Michele on March 6, 2010 - 11:51 am
Quote
“I’m a blogger who really only cares about the writing and the friendship part of the online world” is your brand.
And that’s why I love your blog.

Michele´s last blog ..Yet Another News Article About Mothers "Measuring Up"
#5 by Sarcastica on March 6, 2010 - 12:03 pm
Quote
LOVE LOVE LOVE this post.
heh.
SO damn true, so damn true…I don’t even do product reviews, even though I’ve been sent offers. I just use my blog for writing somewhat incoherent thoughts every once and a while
#6 by Melissa on March 6, 2010 - 1:09 pm
Quote
From one Melissa Beth to another (honest to God, I swear), I love this post. LOVE. IT.
This has been something I’ve been giving much thought about, having been asked for a blogging panel to describe my blog in one sentence. I don’t know what that is. I am too exhausted to concoct dinner, much less a personal brand. My blog is what it is, a hodgepodge of stuff of my life, and if that’s appealing to those who read what I have to say, cool.
Although, if being a brand means being “the best brand of coffee,” then well, sign me up.

Melissa ´s last blog ..Crying Foul Over The Onion
#7 by Susan on March 6, 2010 - 1:17 pm
Quote
When I saw this title in my reader I did that total John Bender Breakfast Club fist pump in air.
yes. Yes! and YES!
I do the eye roll at branding. I hate when branding and community are used in the same sentence, that makes me do the finger down the throat fake gag.
To me branding is limiting and I don’t want to be in a box, labeled and prepackaged. I want to be able to venture out, see new things and write about it.
Susan´s last blog ..The Opposite Reaction
#8 by Joni Golden on March 6, 2010 - 2:53 pm
Quote
Two things…
First: It’s just plain awesome that Stacy wrote what she did. It reminded me that blogs are supposed to be interactive, and we should be supporting and commenting on those we find meaningful or funny or a good read.
Second: She’s right. I really enjoy reading your posts. I never thought much about why, but now I know.
Coffee. Soon.
Joni Golden´s last blog ..Oakland County Board honors women commissioners, past and present
#9 by Jennifer on March 6, 2010 - 6:35 pm
Quote
(stands up clapping) Amen! I agree 100%! I blog because it is an outlet for… everything that goes on in my daily life, and my friends like to read about the crazy stuff that happens to me on a daily basis. I don’t want to be a “brand”. I just want to be me.
Jennifer´s last blog ..Talking with Baby Girl
#10 by Lauren on March 7, 2010 - 12:17 am
Quote
When you are a writer your name is your personal brand but the concept of branding is weird to me and kind of stupid. Can’t I just be self-employed and not be Lauren blah blah blah, LLC? Or whatever. It’s stupid.You’re a rock star.
#11 by LB on March 7, 2010 - 7:57 am
Quote
Girl, I’m right there with you. I just read those folks I enjoy, and write for those folks I, uh, enjoy. I’ve recently dropped a few blogs from my list because they are so commercial. While I do enjoy reading funny stuff about a person’s life, I hate reading about how WONDERFUL they are.
I recently accused of acting naive because I didn’t know anything about blogging stats. I honestly did not know it was possible and had no clue (still don’t) how to capture them. When I said that I only blogged to save money on therapy and to entertain my FB friends, I was laughed at! “Sure,” they said.
WHAT-EVA! Sorry for the ramble. As always, I love your blog. Please don’t laugh at me when I say, “What the hell are you talking about??? Branding?? You are speaking Greek to me.”
LB´s last blog ..The Ugly World of Youth Sports
#12 by Elisa @ Globetrotting in Heels on March 7, 2010 - 9:37 am
Quote
I think the words “personal branding” get thrown around a lot and honestly I can’t even hear it anymore, just like “mommy blogger”, “search engine optimization”, “social media guru”. They all started sounding fake and patronizing a long time ago and I’m just sick of them.
I don’t want to diss those who are making a business out of their blog, but I think to do that you have to have something valuable, a talent. Doing reviews isn’t a talent. Neither is gossiping. Neither is doing a vlog talking about your day. But you know what, as long as we are ourselves and we are honest with our readers, it doesn’t even matter that much.
Elisa @ Globetrotting in Heels´s last blog ..Beauty & Shopping Event: Soirée Beauté at Manor Zurich (Bahnhofstrasse)
#13 by Karie on March 7, 2010 - 1:02 pm
Quote
I read this yesterday while on the road (good thing I wasn’t driving) and my opinion is that they “brand” themselves because they don’t understand that just being yourself is the ticket. Look at you….no branding no nada. Just Melissa writing a kick ass blog. The whole branding thing makes me think of these bloggers who are the “reality TV” types, they offer no real value but do offer a sort of train wreck value that we cannot look away from. I think if they focused more on being themselves and not what they think they are suppose to be or making themselves out to be something they are not (can’t decide on their identity online) they wouldn’t be throwing around the whole “brand” comment.
#14 by dysfunctional mom on March 9, 2010 - 6:20 am
Quote
Yep, and that’s why I love you & your blog.
#15 by MomZombie on March 9, 2010 - 8:41 am
Quote
Personal branding in the personal blogging sphere seems unnecessary to me. I can understand how it applies to companies and entrepreneurs who are trying to establish a Web presence, but it really shouldn’t be attached to everyday folks who want to foster an online community. When I think of personal branding, I think of any one of the Disney kids who are scrubbed, polished, styled and trained to become commodities. Deep underneath the contrived veneer is a real kid dying a little each day. Our blogs are the same way. My favorite ones (yours included) are those that help me feel I’m not alone with my feelings and experiences. I don’t care about your damned Dyson and what it did to your rug.
MomZombie´s last blog ..Apple Blossom
#16 by Beth Warren on March 10, 2010 - 10:52 pm
Quote
I’ve done seminars on branding and think it’s important at times.. the ISSUE is that people get way too serious about it.. friend told me to “stop being the party chick who can’t get a date” or something like that.. dude, that’s not my brand.. that’s who I AM.. which IS my brand. Middle aged chick who kicks ass, takes names and still can’t get a date.. dammit. Maybe I SHOULD work on a new brand.. LMAO
Beth Warren´s last blog ..Are we proud to be Canadian.. or to drink it??
#17 by Shan on March 14, 2010 - 3:11 am
Quote
Thank you for taking a stand! Damn the brand!
I enjoy reading you for you thoughts and content, not that you fit into a certain brand or genre (IMHO anyways).
As a starting blogger, it is nice to see someone more concerned about being authentic. Thank you.
Shan´s last blog ..Ode to the Sucky Inny Thing